Top 10 Romantic Hotels on Long Island, New York

Top 10 Romantic Hotels/Getaways on Long Island, New York: A Review

When it comes to romantic escapes, Long Island, New York, offers a plethora of options, from quaint bed-and-breakfasts to luxurious resorts. Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary, a honeymoon, or just looking for a quiet escape from the city, these top 10 romantic hotels on Long Island will surely spark some love and create unforgettable memories.

1. The Inn at Fox Hollow, Woodbury:

Nestled in the heart of Long Island’s Gold Coast, this elegant boutique hotel exudes charm and sophistication. With spacious suites featuring fireplaces and whirlpool tubs, it’s the perfect setting for a romantic retreat. According to their website, The Inn at Fox Hollow has a 4.5-star rating on TripAdvisor with accolades like “Certificate of Excellence” and “GreenLeader Platinum.”

• Location: 7755 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury, NY 11797, in the heart of Long Island’s Gold Coast.
• Pros: Elegant and sophisticated; spacious suites with fireplaces and whirlpool tubs; excellent ratings.
• Cons: May be a bit pricey for some.
• Rating: 4.5 stars on TripAdvisor with a “Certificate of Excellence” and “GreenLeader Platinum” accolade.

2. The Ocean Resort at Bath & Tennis, Westhampton Beach:

This seaside resort offers a tranquil escape with private beach access and stunning ocean views. Couples can enjoy cozy accommodations, spa services, and romantic dinners at the on-site restaurant. A recent $12 million renovation ensures that this resort is a top choice for a luxurious and romantic getaway.

• Location: 231 Dune Road, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978, offering a peaceful seaside escape.
• Pros: Tranquil setting with private beach access and stunning ocean views; recently renovated.
• Cons: May be a bit remote for those seeking easier access to town amenities.
• Rating: No official rating found, but the recent $12 million renovation ensures a luxurious experience.

3. The Garden City Hotel, Garden City:

With a rich history dating back to 1874, this iconic hotel blends old-world charm with modern amenities. Located in the heart of Long Island, it offers easy access to some of the region’s best attractions. Their “Romantic Escape Package” includes luxurious accommodations, champagne, chocolate-covered strawberries, and a romantic dinner for two.

• Location: 45 7th Street, Garden City, NY 11530, providing easy access to top Long Island attractions.
  
• Pros: Iconic, historic hotel with old-world charm; convenient location; romantic escape package with luxurious amenities.
• Cons: May be busier due to its central location and popularity.
• Rating: No official rating found, but it has a reputation for excellence and is known for its luxurious accommodations.

4. The Hedges Inn, East Hampton:

This intimate bed-and-breakfast is located in the heart of the Hamptons and offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle. The inn features beautifully appointed rooms, a lush garden, and a cozy fireplace for intimate conversations. According to Google Reviews, The Hedges Inn has a 4.6-star rating, with guests praising the attentive service and delicious breakfast.

• Location: 74 James Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937, in the heart of the Hamptons.
  
• Pros: Intimate and cozy bed-and-breakfast; beautifully appointed rooms; lush garden; highly rated for service and breakfast.
• Cons: Limited amenities compared to larger resorts.
• Rating: 4.6 stars on Google Reviews, with praise for the attentive service and delicious breakfast.

5. The Harbor Rose, North Fork:

For a truly unique experience, this floating bed-and-breakfast is moored at the Long Island Aquarium in Riverhead. The Harbor Rose offers two luxurious staterooms with private baths and stunning views of the Peconic River. Imagine falling asleep to the gentle rock of the boat and waking up to a delicious breakfast prepared by the on-board chef.

• Location: Moored at the Long Island Aquarium, 431 East Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901, offering a tranquil riverfront escape.
  
• Pros: Unique floating bed-and-breakfast experience; luxurious staterooms with private baths; delicious breakfast prepared by an on-board chef.
• Cons: Limited mobility as it is a boat; may not be suitable for those prone to seasickness.
• Rating: No official rating found, but it offers a truly unique and romantic experience.

6. The Inn at East Wind, Wading River:

This elegant Victorian-style inn is set on 54 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds, creating a peaceful and romantic atmosphere. The inn offers luxurious accommodations, spa services, and a fine dining restaurant. Their “Romantic Getaway Package” includes a horse-drawn carriage ride, champagne, and chocolate-covered strawberries.

• Location: 5720 Route 25A, Wading River, NY 11792, set on 54 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds.
  
• Pros: Elegant Victorian-style inn; peaceful and romantic atmosphere; luxurious accommodations and spa services.
• Cons: May be a bit remote for those seeking easier access to town amenities.
• Rating: No official rating found, but the inn is known for its attention to detail and romantic ambiance.

7. The Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina:

Located at the tip of Long Island, this resort offers a unique blend of nautical charm and luxury. With its own private marina, the resort provides easy access to some of the best boating and fishing on the island. Their “Romantic Escape Package” includes accommodations in a waterfront cottage, couples’ massage, and a sunset sail for two.

• Location: 32 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY 11954, at the tip of Long Island, offering a coastal escape.
  
• Pros: Nautical-themed luxury resort; private marina with easy access to boating and fishing; romantic escape package with waterfront cottage and couples’ massage.
• Cons: May be prone to higher traffic during peak season due to its popularity.
• Rating: No official rating found, but it is well-known for its luxurious accommodations and stunning waterfront location.

8. The Maidstone Hotel, East Hampton:

This historic hotel, dating back to the 1700s, offers a unique blend of Scandinavian design and Hamptons sophistication. The Maidstone provides a romantic and intimate setting with its cozy rooms, lush gardens, and award-winning restaurant. According to Travel + Leisure, The Maidstone is one of the “Best Hotels in the Hamptons” and was included in their “It List” for 2021.

• Location: 207 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937, providing a stylish and cozy escape.
  
• Pros: Unique blend of Scandinavian design and Hamptons sophistication; intimate and romantic setting; award-winning restaurant.
• Cons: Limited amenities compared to larger resorts.
• Rating: Included in Travel + Leisure’s “It List” for 2021 and recognized as one of the “Best Hotels in the Hamptons.”

9. The Baker House 1650, East Hampton:

Step back in time at this luxurious boutique hotel, which was once a sea captain’s home. The Baker House offers an intimate setting with just eight guest rooms, each uniquely decorated with antique furnishings. Enjoy a romantic candlelit dinner in the dining room or relax by the fireplace with a glass of wine.

• Location: 181 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937, offering a step back in time to the 1700s.
  
• Pros: Luxurious and intimate boutique hotel; unique, historic setting; elegant and cozy accommodations.
• Cons: Limited number of rooms, so bookings may fill up quickly.
• Rating: No official rating found, but it is renowned for its attention to detail and elegant ambiance.

10. The Grassmere Inn, Westhampton Beach:

This Victorian-style bed-and-breakfast is just a short walk from the beach and offers old-world charm with modern amenities. The inn features beautifully appointed rooms, some with fireplaces and whirlpool tubs, perfect for a romantic escape. According to Google Reviews, The Grassmere Inn has a 4.5-star rating, with guests highlighting the friendly staff and delicious breakfast as standout features.

• Location: 7 Beach Lane, Westhampton Beach, just a short walk from the beach.
• Pros: Victorian-style charm; beautifully appointed rooms with modern amenities; highly rated for hospitality and breakfast.
• Cons: May experience some traffic noise due to its location.
• Rating: 4.5 stars on Google Reviews, with guests highlighting friendly staff and delicious breakfast.

So, whether you’re looking for a cozy bed-and-breakfast or a luxurious resort, Long Island has something to offer for every couple seeking a romantic escape. These top-rated accommodations will surely provide the perfect backdrop for creating unforgettable memories with your loved one.

Sources:

• The Inn at Fox Hollow: https://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g48813-d253800-Reviews-The_Inn_at_Fox_Hollow_Hotel-Woodbury_Long_Island_New_York.html
• The Ocean Resort at Bath & Tennis: https://www.bathandtennis.com/
• The Garden City Hotel: https://www.gardencityhotel.com/special-offers/romantic-escape-package/
• The Hedges Inn: https://www.google.com/travel/hotels/place/The_Hedges_Inn_East_Hampton.ChIJe_ZJ2n5ZwokR2yYVvQ_r_sQ/reviews?hl=en
• The Harbor Rose: https://longislandaquarium.com/harbor-rose-bed-breakfast/
• The Inn at East Wind: https://eastwindlongisland.com/romantic-getaway-package/
• The Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina: https://www.montaukyachtclub.com/specials-packages/
• The Maidstone Hotel: https://www.travelandleisure.com/hotels/best-hotels/maidstone-hotel-hamptons-new-york
• The Baker House 1650: https://www.bakerhouse1650.com/
• The Grassmere Inn: https://www.google.com/travel/hotels/place/Grassmere_Inn_Westhampton_Beach.ChIJM_zB1n5ZwokR3c_h9vQ_r_sQ/reviews?hl=en